Nic's Trattoria

Danielle Mashiah 2 months ago

PERFECTION. Food was BOMB. Atmosphere great especially outside, drinks delicious and strong, service was really charming! Highly recommend. Cutlet was perfection, aranchini crisp to perfection, meatballs were legit delicate and flavorful, hot honey pizza was sooooooo good. A must try! And must return!

Scott Vining Edited 2 months ago

Brought my mother in for lunch. We just had salad, pizza and cocktails. The service was fantastic and the cocktails were very good. When the salads came out my mother asked for extra dressing and without hesitation our server was back with more. The salads were great but the pizza was amazing. The atmosphere was very nice, ran into some friends and stayed for hours on a Saturday afternoon

Kristen 3 years ago

We’ve been here about a dozen times and each time it’s been amazing start to finish- the food, staff and atmosphere are all amazing. They have a unique menu with different specials running every night and their cocktails are strong and delicious. We will continue to visit and bring new friends and family!

russineastgreenbush 3 years ago

This was our first time at Nic's. We just moved up to the area and were looking for a great Italian place. We found it! We made a reservation through OT and when we arrived our table was ready. Liz, our server, came over to our table a short while later to take our drink orders. Just before they arrived she took our food order. Everything was fresh, well presented with good portion sizes. A whipped ricotta starter was fantastic as was the perfectly cooked fried calamari. The wood fired pizza, the "Fungi", was delicious with an assortment of mushrooms. The flavor was great and the crust was nice and crispy. The chicken parmesan was also excellent and a very large portion. We were full and took food home. Liz was amazing; friendly, welcoming and efficient. We're definitely going to return. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!

Tonys Best 4 years ago

Outstanding! Very thin, Neapolitan style pizza. This isn't your everyday street corner pizza. our pizzas were made with clearly quality ingredients and a delicious pizza dough. The pizzas are about 11 in, which could have been enough for two. we didn't realize so we ordered one for each of ourselves and we both had about two slices to take home which is about half a pie. I had the classic and ordered sausage and my daughter had the mushroom. both were outstanding delicate but yet full-of flavor. The sauce was light and had a garden tomato flavor (imagine that!) The other items on the menu looked delicious. we'll have to try them next time. The pies came out very quickly. The service was friendly. It was busy. If you like a high quality well prepared pizza, this is a good place to go. We arrived at 5:30 on a Saturday afternoon and did not have reservations, but we were able to sit outside on the patio which is very nice and on a beautiful spring day it was an enjoyable experience.